Skip to content
medium-roast
Monday 16 November 2026

We read sixteen accounts of starting with no audience, fifteen in the founders' own words and one, Stripe's, in its investor's, and counted what each says brought the first users. The sixteen were gathered by hand, not found by a search rule. Among them, six wrote to people one at a time, more than any other way. Three got them from one post on the Hacker News front page, and three by posting where their niche already gathers. Every number is the account's own claim. Pages read 6 October 2026.

How did founders get their first users? Most often by writing to people, one at a time

6 of 16
wrote to people one at a time
3 of 16
one post reached the Hacker News front page
3 of 16
posted or commented where their niche gathers
2 of 16
launch posts brought nothing at first

The rule

Fifteen cases are a founder writing in their own words, on their own blog, in an interview or on a forum, about the users they had before anyone knew them; the sixteenth, Stripe, is its investor's telling. Each is counted once, by the move the founder credits for those first users. Where a founder doesn't say, we say so rather than guess. Every case, its link and its founder's words are in the table below, so anyone can re-sort it. The sixteen were gathered by hand, from founders’ blogs and newsletters, interviews, Indie Hackers and Hacker News threads, and one investor’s essay, as we came across them, not by a systematic search; another sixteen could tell it differently.

The six who wrote to people

Tally, a form builder made by two people, made lists of people who had shown interest in similar products and wrote to each: “We scanned Product Hunt and Twitter and made lists of hundreds of prospects and started doing cold outreach, asking for their feedback. Often without success, but those who did take the time to reply became part of our community of early users and ambassadors.” (Tally's blog). Tally reports “a small community of 1.500 users” (1,500: their notation) before its Product Hunt launch.

The founder of Inbox When Ready found people who had been lukewarm about a rival product: “I spent a day or so manually emailing several hundred people in this way.” It brought “100 WAU within a couple of weeks” (Hacker News comment).

Saner.ai's founder was banned from subreddits for promotional posts, then wrote to people directly: “Every post, every person — I reached out to them all.” (Indie Hackers). OnlineOrNot's founder got 54 sign-ups from a year of articles, and “1 paid user (who I sold to personally, rather than relying on content marketing)” (his blog). An unnamed founder in April 2026, reaching out on LinkedIn: “I have gotten 35 users as of yet with this approach in the last 2 weeks.” (Hacker News comment). And Stripe, in its investor's telling rather than the founders': “When anyone agreed to try Stripe they'd say "Right then, give me your laptop" and set them up on the spot.” (Paul Graham).

What the launch sites did

None of the sixteen credits Product Hunt for its first users, but it isn't nothing. Inbox When Ready's founder: “Listing sites, in particular, were largely a waste of time, though my Product Hunt submission came good when the extension was featured a few months later.” (Hacker News comment). Buildpad's first paying customers arrived in the month of its Product Hunt launch, seven months in, after its first users had come from a Reddit survey (Buildpad's story). DevUtils' founder posted on Product Hunt after a Hacker News spike, and “got another traffic spike, and that was it” (his newsletter).

Two founders say their launches brought nothing at first. ScreenshotOne: “Despite zero sales initially, persistence paid off with the first paying customer once a month after the launch.” (interview). SimpleLogin: “I launched via different websites (HackerNews, BetaPage, etc) but these were never a real success.” (interview).

What's working

Among these sixteen, writing to people worked for the most founders, and none of the six says it scales. The Hacker News front page worked three times, and none of the sixteen says it could have been planned. DevUtils' founder calls his post lucky: “I think I got lucky, the post received some positive comments” (his newsletter).

Every case

ProductWhat brought the first users, in the account's wordsCounted as
Tally“started doing cold outreach, asking for their feedback” (blog)wrote to people
Inbox When Ready“manually emailing several hundred people” (HN)wrote to people
Saner.ai“Every post, every person — I reached out to them all.” (IH)wrote to people
OnlineOrNot“who I sold to personally, rather than relying on content marketing” (blog)wrote to people
Unnamed tool, 2026“reaching out to them on linked in and talking about my own problem with them” (HN)wrote to people
Stripe“Right then, give me your laptop” (Paul Graham)wrote to people
DevUtils“I got to the top of Hacker News for a few hours. And that’s how I got my first ever internet dollar.” (newsletter)Hacker News front page
Simple Analytics“The Hacker News launch got me my first 30 paying customers” (LinkedIn)Hacker News front page
Healthchecks.io“I've had only one article get upvoted to the Hacker News front page. This was in our first year and brought in a good amount of early users.” (IH interview, archived)Hacker News front page
Standard Notes“Comment on privacy related HN posts about a privacy-focused notes app. That would have gotten me 40-50 users.” (HN)where the niche gathers
Buildpad“we shared it with the same people who had previously given us feedback” and “we made a launch post in their subreddit” (blog)where the niche gathers
1000 Pound Club“In total, I got 55 registered users from the Reddit launch.” (IH)where the niche gathers
ScreenshotOne“Despite zero sales initially, persistence paid off with the first paying customer once a month after the launch.” (interview)launches brought nothing at first
SimpleLogin“these were never a real success” and “Our growth is until now organic and mostly via word-of-mouth.” (interview)launches brought nothing at first
Plausible“We had 60 active beta users at this point, and some decided to stick around and pay for our service too.” Where the 60 came from isn't said (blog)doesn't say
Zestful (Michael Lynch)“I put the project in maintenance mode in September after several months of unsuccessful sales attempts.” Among the doubts he says he frequently asks himself: “One of your fatal flaws with Zestful was that you were too afraid of sales.” (blog)several months of unsuccessful sales attempts